“We just haven’t found the right wake window yet.”There is no right wake window

Sleep pressure is real physiology. Wake window charts are something we have built on top of it, and those aren't quite the same thing.

01Wake windows

Wake windows are not the same thing as sleep pressure

If you've come here looking for wake windows by age, I'm going to disappoint you slightly. I'm not going to give you a chart.

The idea that babies of a particular age should be awake for a prescribed amount of time before their next sleep has become incredibly popular. You'll find wake window charts all over social media, parenting websites and sleep tracking apps. But wake windows, as they are commonly presented to parents, are not a concept that comes from sleep science.

That doesn't mean the amount of time a baby has been awake is irrelevant. Far from it.

One of the things that influences our ability to fall asleep is homeostatic sleep pressure. Broadly speaking, sleep pressure builds while we are awake and reduces while we sleep. So, of course, how long a baby has been awake matters.

But it isn't the only thing that matters.

The two-process model of sleep regulation describes two interacting processes: homeostatic sleep pressure and the circadian system (Borbély, 1982). The first helps explain why we become increasingly ready for sleep the longer we are awake. The second helps determine when our bodies are biologically more inclined towards sleep or wakefulness across the 24-hour day.

A wake window chart takes one small part of that much more complicated system and turns it into a number.

The problem isn't looking at the clock. Time can be useful information. The problem is assuming that there is a correct amount of time every baby of a particular age should be awake, and that if sleep is difficult, the answer must be to keep adjusting that number until we get it right.

Sometimes a baby who isn't settling simply doesn't have enough sleep pressure yet. Sometimes their circadian rhythm is promoting wakefulness. Sometimes the proposed nap or bedtime doesn't fit particularly well with the rest of their day. Sometimes something entirely different is going on.

This is also why simply moving bedtime earlier and earlier doesn't necessarily solve bedtime battles. There is a period before our biological night when the circadian system actively promotes wakefulness, sometimes described as the wake maintenance zone. If we try to create sleep at a time when the body is strongly promoting alertness, we may end up with a long struggle at bedtime or a baby who sleeps briefly and then wakes ready for more awake time.

That doesn't mean every false start or difficult bedtime has a circadian explanation. It means that sleep is more complicated than counting the minutes since the last nap.

When I look at a sleep diary, I'm interested in much more than whether a baby has followed an age-based wake window. I want to know how much sleep this particular child is actually getting, how sleep is distributed across the day and night, when they seem naturally ready for sleep, what happens when sleep is offered, how feeding fits into the picture, what else is happening developmentally and, importantly, how the family is experiencing all of this.

The clock can give us information. It just shouldn't be the boss.

Children respond differently to sleep pressure too

There is another layer to this that wake window charts can't capture: children vary in how sensitive they are to high sleep pressure.

Some children cope remarkably well with being awake for a long time. Sleep pressure builds, they become increasingly ready for sleep, and eventually they fall asleep without too much drama.

Other children seem much less comfortable when sleep pressure becomes high. They may become irritable, dysregulated, frantic, silly or increasingly difficult to settle. Parents often describe these children as 'overtired'. I'm not a fan of the word 'overtired' – it misses the point and overlooks nuance. But that doesn't mean we ignore parental observation of a real experience.

Parents and practitioners are often describing something very real. The problem comes when an observation of behaviour is turned into a physiological explanation that the evidence doesn't support.

You will commonly hear, for example, that an 'overtired' baby has missed their sleep window, that their body has become flooded with cortisol, or that they have become so tired that they are now unable to sleep. Those explanations are repeated so often that they can sound like established sleep science.

But there is a simpler way to understand what we may be seeing.

Some children become dysregulated when sleep pressure gets very high. And a dysregulated child may find it harder to become calm enough to settle to sleep.

That distinction matters. It isn't necessarily the tiredness itself that is preventing sleep. The child hasn't crossed an invisible threshold after which sleep suddenly becomes physiologically more difficult. They may simply need more help to regulate before they can settle.

And crucially, once they do become calm, the sleep pressure hasn't disappeared. It is still there. They are still tired, and they can still sleep.

This is why I am cautious about using 'overtired' as a binary explanation for sleep difficulties. It can become circular very quickly: the baby isn't sleeping because they're overtired, and we know they're overtired because they aren't sleeping.

Instead, I find it much more useful to ask what happens to this particular child as sleep pressure builds.

Do they become increasingly sleepy and settle easily? Do they remain cheerful for a surprisingly long time? Or is there a point at which their nervous system seems to become overwhelmed and they need considerably more support to regulate?

For a child who is particularly sensitive to high sleep pressure, offering sleep before they reach that point of dysregulation may make settling much easier. Another child may tolerate much longer periods of wakefulness perfectly happily and need considerably more sleep pressure before they are ready to fall asleep.

Neither child is doing sleep incorrectly.

And this is one of the reasons I am wary of prescribing the same wake window to every baby of the same age. Even if two children had identical sleep needs, it wouldn't necessarily follow that they would respond to increasing sleep pressure in exactly the same way.

The useful question isn't simply 'How long has this baby been awake?' It is also 'What happens to this particular baby as sleep pressure builds?'

As seen in
The Guardian
Neonatal Nurses Association
Attachment Parenting UK
BDA Journal of Human Nutrition & Dietetics
Raised Good
My Baba
All for Birth
Epidemic Answers
International Breastfeeding Journal
02Variability

Sleep needs vary, sometimes by a lot

The next piece of the puzzle is individual sleep need.

Just as adults vary in how much sleep they need, babies and children do too. It can be useful in practice to think broadly about children as having relatively low, average or high sleep needs, although these aren't diagnostic categories and there isn't a test that neatly assigns a child to one of them.

Some children consistently seem to function well on less sleep than the average for their age. Others genuinely seem to need more. Most sit somewhere in between.

And sleep need isn't necessarily fixed forever. It changes enormously with age and development, and illness, activity, health and other circumstances can affect sleep too.

What matters is that the variation between healthy children is substantial.

Some of our best longitudinal data on children's sleep demonstrates a wide distribution of sleep duration across childhood. Iglowstein and colleagues (2003), for example, found considerable variation between children at the same age. Galland and colleagues' (2012) systematic review similarly found substantial variation in sleep duration and sleep patterns between healthy children.

So two healthy eight-month-olds can need quite different amounts of sleep across 24 hours. They may also distribute that sleep differently. One may naturally take longer naps and another shorter ones. One may sleep for a longer stretch overnight while another has more daytime sleep.

This is where averages can become accidentally prescriptive.

Population averages are useful for understanding broad developmental patterns, but an average describes a population. It doesn't tell us exactly how much sleep an individual child requires.

If a relatively low-sleep-needs child is repeatedly offered the amount of sleep expected of a higher-sleep-needs child, we may inadvertently create difficulties that look remarkably like a sleep problem: long periods awake during the night, resistance at bedtime, lengthy attempts to achieve naps or a family spending large parts of the day trying to make a baby sleep.

The reverse matters too. A child with relatively high sleep needs may struggle if their opportunities for sleep routinely don't allow them to meet those needs.

And importantly, sleep need and sleep pressure sensitivity aren't the same thing.

A child can have relatively low sleep needs but be quite sensitive when their sleep pressure becomes high. Another child might need more sleep overall but tolerate increasing sleep pressure remarkably well.

These are different characteristics, and both help us understand why two children of exactly the same age can respond very differently to the same schedule.

This is why assessment matters.

The aim isn't to work out which chart is right. It is to understand the child in front of us.

This way of working has a name, holistic sleep coaching (Hookway, 2026), and a framework behind it that can be properly learned.

Learn more about holistic sleep coaching →
03Chronobiology

Babies aren't born with a mature body clock

Babies do have the beginnings of a circadian timing system before they are born. What they don't have is the mature, consolidated day–night rhythm we recognise in older children and adults.

Circadian organisation develops progressively during early infancy. Rhythms in melatonin, cortisol, body temperature, sleep and wakefulness emerge and consolidate on slightly different developmental timetables, with much more recognisable day–night organisation developing over the first few months (Rivkees, 2003).

This helps explain something very ordinary about newborn sleep.

A newborn who sleeps and wakes across the whole 24-hour day hasn't got their days and nights wrong, and they haven't learned a bad habit. Their sleep–wake system is still developing.

That changes the conversation about newborn sleep.

Rather than expecting very young babies to conform to rigid clock-based schedules, we can support the environmental cues involved in developing circadian organisation. Light and darkness matter. Feeding and social interaction provide cues. The rhythms of family life gradually help babies make sense of day and night.

This doesn't mean routines are bad. Predictable patterns can be useful and reassuring for families. It simply means that our expectations need to match the developmental physiology of the baby in front of us.

Understanding chronobiology gives us something much more useful than another rule about what time a baby should go to bed. It helps us understand why the same strategy can work beautifully at one point in development and make very little sense at another.

04Sleep architecture

Babies don't sleep like small adults

Infant sleep isn't simply adult sleep in shorter chunks.

Newborn babies spend a much larger proportion of sleep in active sleep, the developmental precursor to REM sleep, than adults do. Active sleep is thought to play an important role in early brain development, providing endogenous stimulation during a period of extraordinarily rapid neurological growth (Roffwarg et al., 1966).

Sleep organisation also changes enormously across infancy and childhood.

Young babies have shorter sleep cycles than adults and transition frequently between sleep states. They may move, twitch, vocalise, briefly open their eyes or appear surprisingly restless while still asleep. They may surface between sleep cycles and sometimes need support to return to sleep.

Understanding this can be enormously reassuring for parents.

A baby stirring after a relatively short period of sleep hasn't necessarily been disturbed, developed a bad habit or failed to learn how to 'link' sleep cycles. Arousal and transitions between sleep states are normal parts of sleep.

Of course, frequent waking isn't automatically explained by sleep architecture either. If a baby is waking very frequently, seems uncomfortable, is struggling with feeding, has breathing concerns or the family simply feels that something isn't right, those things deserve proper assessment.

Normalising infant sleep should never mean dismissing parents' concerns.

The useful question is not simply 'How do we make this baby sleep for longer?' It is 'What might be contributing to the sleep we're seeing?'

Holistic sleep coaching covers the whole of childhood, birth through the teenage years, in one evidence-based framework.

Learn more about holistic sleep coaching →
05Arousal

Waking is part of sleep, not the opposite of it

We often talk about sleep and waking as though they are two completely separate states: a good sleeper remains asleep and a poor sleeper wakes.

Physiology is rather more complicated.

Brief arousals occur throughout normal sleep in children and adults. In young infants, arousal mechanisms are also part of an immature but developing system involved in responding to changes in breathing and the environment. Impaired arousal responses have been one area of investigation in SIDS research (McKenna & McDade, 2005).

That doesn't mean that frequent night waking protects a baby from SIDS, or that every behavioural waking has a protective purpose. Physiological arousal and a baby fully waking and signalling for a parent are not the same thing.

But it does remind us that the goal of healthy infant sleep isn't to create a baby who never arouses.

When a family tells me that their baby wakes frequently, I don't want to jump immediately to 'How do we stop it?'

I want to understand the waking first.

Is this broadly what we might expect for this child's age and developmental stage? Is hunger involved? Could discomfort, breathing, illness or feeding difficulties be contributing? Is the child being offered more sleep than they need? Has something changed developmentally? How much support do they need to return to sleep? And perhaps most importantly, what is making this pattern difficult for this particular family?

Sometimes the baby doesn't need fixing at all, but the family does need more support.

Sometimes there is something we can change.

Knowing the difference is the skill.

06Feeding

Night feeds are not simply a sleep problem to eliminate

Feeding and sleep are deeply intertwined during infancy.

This can get lost when night feeding is framed primarily as a sleep association that needs to be broken before a baby can sleep for longer periods.

Research has found associations between breastfeeding and more frequent night waking or shorter uninterrupted periods of sleep, but that doesn't mean breastfeeding causes poor sleep, nor does it mean breastfed babies are getting inadequate sleep overall.

Pennestri and colleagues (2018), for example, found that infants who were not sleeping through according to the study definitions were more likely to be breastfed. Importantly, sleeping through was not associated with better mental or psychomotor development.

Research by St James-Roberts and colleagues (2015) also found that, at three months, exclusively breastfed babies were just as likely as formula or mixed-fed babies to self-resettle during observed night-time sleep and to have long sleep periods.

So feeding to sleep doesn't automatically create a baby who is incapable of returning to sleep without feeding.

Night feeding can also be important to breastfeeding itself, particularly during early infancy and while milk production is being established. Advice to deliberately space feeds, remove night feeds or separate feeding from sleep therefore needs to take account of the baby's age, feeding effectiveness, growth, milk supply and the family's breastfeeding goals.

This doesn't mean breastfeeding families can never make changes to night feeding.

It means sleep advice shouldn't be given in a vacuum.

A family may want to change how nights work. They may be exhausted. They may want another parent to become more involved. An older baby or toddler may be feeding frequently overnight and the breastfeeding parent may genuinely want to reduce that.

Responsive sleep support should be able to hold both things at once: protecting feeding where that matters to the family, while also taking parental wellbeing and the need for change seriously.

References
  1. Borbély, A. A. (1982). A two process model of sleep regulation. Human Neurobiology, 1(3), 195–204.
  2. Galland, B. C., Taylor, B. J., Elder, D. E., & Herbison, P. (2012). Normal sleep patterns in infants and children: A systematic review of observational studies. Sleep Medicine Reviews, 16(3), 213–222.
  3. Iglowstein, I., Jenni, O. G., Molinari, L., & Largo, R. H. (2003). Sleep duration from infancy to adolescence: Reference values and generational trends. Pediatrics, 111(2), 302–307.
  4. McKenna, J. J., & McDade, T. (2005). Why babies should never sleep alone: A review of the co-sleeping controversy in relation to SIDS, bedsharing and breast feeding. Paediatric Respiratory Reviews, 6(2), 134–152.
  5. Pennestri, M.-H., Laganiere, C., Bouvette-Turcot, A.-A., Pokhvisneva, I., Steiner, M., Meaney, M. J., & Gaudreau, H. (2018). Uninterrupted infant sleep, development, and maternal mood. Pediatrics, 142(6), e20174330.
  6. Rivkees, S. A. (2003). Developing circadian rhythmicity in infants. Pediatrics, 112(2), 373–381.
  7. Roffwarg, H. P., Muzio, J. N., & Dement, W. C. (1966). Ontogenetic development of the human sleep-dream cycle. Science, 152(3722), 604–619.
  8. St James-Roberts, I., Roberts, M., Hovish, K., & Owen, C. (2015). Video evidence that London infants can resettle themselves back to sleep after waking in the night, as well as sleep for long periods, by 3 months of age. Journal of Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics, 36(5), 324–329.
Where all of this leads

This is why holistic sleep coaching exists

None of these ideas belong to an alternative version of sleep science. Sleep pressure, circadian biology, developmental changes in sleep architecture, individual variability, arousal and the relationship between feeding and sleep are all part of understanding how humans sleep.

What is often missing is the opportunity to bring those pieces together.

Many of the professionals who come to our training already know how to listen to families, assess children holistically and think critically about health and development. What they haven't necessarily been given is enough depth in sleep physiology to apply those existing skills confidently to sleep.

That is the gap holistic sleep coaching is designed to fill.

It isn't about replacing wake window charts with a different set of rules.

It is about understanding the biology well enough that we need fewer rules in the first place.

It means being able to look beyond 'How do we get this baby to sleep?' and ask better questions.

  • What is developmentally normal here?
  • How much sleep might this particular child actually need?
  • How do they respond as sleep pressure builds?
  • What might be contributing to the pattern we're seeing?
  • Is there anything that needs further assessment?
  • What does this particular child appear to need?
  • What is sustainable for this particular family?
  • And what, if anything, actually needs to change?

Because sometimes the most useful thing we can offer a family isn't another number to aim for. It's helping them understand the child they already have.

700+
Professionals trained
7 yrs
Industry leading
4.9/5
Google rating
OCN L6
Accredited
104
Live supervision sessions a year, included
18.75
CERPs for IBCLCs

The Holistic Sleep Coaching Program is where practitioners learn it properly. It is, as far as I know, the most in-depth training of its kind available anywhere: accredited at Level 6 through the Open College Network, the same level of academic difficulty as final-year undergraduate study. It is taught by a faculty of 25+ specialists, and practised under live clinical supervision with me, week in, week out, for as long as you work.

It's built for people who already work with families: doulas, IBCLCs, health visitors, midwives, occupational therapists, sleep practitioners who trained elsewhere and wanted more depth, and career changers who are serious about doing this properly. Whatever families originally hired you for, the sleep question always finds you. This is how you answer it with your whole chest. And if you already know this is your direction, book a free call and talk it through with our team.

Watch the free 4-part video training

Enter your details below and we'll send you straight to the Holistic Sleep Coaching Revolution: a free video series with Dr Lyndsey Hookway and Emma Dewey. You'll see why surface-level sleep advice often falls short, how to support families responsively while still achieving results, and how to build a trusted sleep consultancy on that foundation. Instant access — watch at your own pace.

What's your number one challenge when it comes to supporting families with sleep?

Completely free, with instant access — watch in any order that suits you. You'll also receive our emails about all things sleep; unsubscribe any time. We protect your details in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

In their own words

What happens when practitioners choose depth

“Fully booked in less than 12 months.”

Lucy Bagwell

“6 clients a month to 6 a week, with a waitlist.”

Karla

“The Holistic programme goes into areas that other courses just don't touch, and as a result it has given me the breadth and depth of knowledge I was really looking for.”

Rachael TaylorRachael TaylorSleep Coach

“For me it was a degree-level professional education on everything you need to know about sleep, not just a philosophy to follow. I've done lots of training and hands down this is the most comprehensive.”

Nadia EdwardsNadia EdwardsHSCP Graduate
Before you ask

Frequently asked questions

What is holistic sleep coaching?
Holistic sleep coaching supports family sleep by looking far beyond a set of sleep-training strategies. Instead of one-size-fits-all techniques, a holistic sleep coach considers the whole picture (infant and child sleep biology, feeding, development, health, temperament, attachment and the parents' own goals) and helps families improve sleep gently and responsively, protecting the parent-child relationship.
How is it different from traditional sleep training?
Traditional sleep training often relies on a fixed set of behavioural techniques, some of which are non-responsive and conflict with a family's parenting values. Holistic sleep coaching gets results without resorting to those techniques. It's grounded in evidence and biology, tailored to each family, and focused on understanding why a child isn't sleeping, so you can support even complex cases with confidence.
Is the programme accredited?
Yes, at Level 6 through the Open College Network (OCN), the largest vocational awarding body in the UK. Accreditation means teaching and assessment standards are upheld through rigorous internal and external verification, so you can be confident in the quality and depth of your training.
Do I need previous qualifications or experience to join?
The programme suits practitioners who already support families (health visitors, midwives, IBCLCs, maternity nurses, doulas, occupational therapists and childcare professionals) as well as people building a new career with real commitment. It's self-paced and designed to fit around full-time work; what matters most is a genuine commitment to evidence-based, responsive practice.
What support do I get during and after the course?
Support goes far beyond the modules. While training, you join a private community with 104 live clinical supervision sessions a year with Dr Lyndsey Hookway and regular live business development sessions with Emma Dewey, all included, where most programmes charge thousands extra. After you graduate, you keep the community, ongoing masterclasses and mentorship, because the real learning starts once you're working with families.
What is your refund and cancellation policy?

Within 14 days of purchase: you can cancel and request a full refund.

After 14 days: cancellations are not eligible for a refund.

To request a refund, email info@babyem.co.uk.

Still reading? That's usually a sign.

Watch the free training →
Learn more about holistic sleep coaching
Built with BernardCookie settings