‘Is he sleeping through yet?’
What the research tells us about one of the most loaded questions in parenting.
It's one of those questions that sounds straightforward until you stop and think about what we're actually asking. Do we mean that the baby doesn't wake? That they don't feed? That they don't call for a parent? That they sleep for six hours? Eight hours? From the parent's bedtime until morning? And perhaps more importantly, why does it matter?
For some families, the answer is obvious: they are exhausted and desperately need more sleep. For others, there is a worry that their baby should be sleeping for longer by now. Sometimes a parent is perfectly happy with their baby's sleep until someone else tells them they shouldn't be. So before we decide that a baby needs to sleep through, it helps to understand what sleeping through actually means.
Sleeping, waking and signalling are not the same thing
One of my favourite infant sleep studies involved researchers filming 101 babies overnight using infrared video recordings (St James-Roberts et al., 2015). The recordings allowed the researchers to see something parents can't usually see: what babies do when nobody else is awake.
Some babies woke and signalled for their parents. Others woke and returned to sleep without signalling. At just five weeks old, around a quarter of the babies showed some ability to resettle after waking.
That's important because when a parent tells us that their baby slept through, what they can really tell us is that their baby didn't wake them. The baby may genuinely have slept for a long uninterrupted period. They may also have briefly woken, moved around, made a few noises and returned to sleep without anybody knowing.
This isn't peculiar to babies. Human sleep isn't one continuous state of unconsciousness. We move through different sleep stages and experience brief arousals throughout the night.
So there are several different things we might be interested in when we talk about infant sleep: how much sleep a baby gets altogether, how long their periods of sleep are, how often they wake and whether they signal for somebody when they do.
Those things are related, but they aren't interchangeable.
Sleeping through isn't a milestone that happens on a particular night
There isn't a universally agreed definition of sleeping through. Some research has defined it as six hours of uninterrupted sleep. Other studies use eight hours. Parents may have something entirely different in mind, usually involving a stretch of sleep that allows them to get some decent sleep themselves. Whatever definition we choose, the age at which babies begin sleeping for longer uninterrupted periods varies enormously.
Pennestri and colleagues (2018) studied 388 infants and found that at six months, 38% had not yet slept for six uninterrupted hours and 57% had not slept for eight. At 12 months, 28% were not yet sleeping for six uninterrupted hours and 43% were not sleeping for eight.
But even those figures miss something important. Being capable of sleeping for six or eight hours isn't the same as doing it consistently. Pennestri and colleagues explored this in a later study (2020), asking parents of 44 six-month-old babies to complete sleep diaries over 13 nights. Only 6.8% of the babies slept for six consecutive hours on every night of the study. Just 2.3% slept for eight consecutive hours every night.
Some babies achieved those stretches on some nights but not others, and 20.5% never slept for six consecutive hours during the observation period. Half of the babies never managed an eight-hour stretch. That gives us a very different picture from the idea that a baby reaches a particular age, starts sleeping through and then continues doing it.
Longer stretches of sleep tend to become more common as babies develop, but development isn't linear. A baby might sleep for eight hours tonight and wake three times tomorrow night. Illness, feeding, development, discomfort, separation, changes in routine and countless other things can alter sleep.
Sleeping through is better understood as something that becomes increasingly likely with development than a milestone a baby achieves once and keeps.
This way of working has a name, holistic sleep coaching (Hookway, 2026), and a framework behind it that can be properly learned.
Learn more about holistic sleep coaching →Does sleeping through matter for development?
One reason sleeping through has become so important is the assumption that consolidated sleep is necessary for healthy development. Sleep itself is enormously important. But that isn't the same as saying that a baby needs to obtain their sleep in one long uninterrupted block.
Pennestri and colleagues (2018) looked at whether infants who slept for six or eight uninterrupted hours at six and twelve months differed on measures of mental and psychomotor development. They didn't find a significant association. That doesn't mean sleep doesn't matter for development. Of course it does.
It tells us something much more specific: in this study, achieving the particular milestone of sleeping for six or eight uninterrupted hours wasn't associated with better developmental outcomes. That distinction matters. A baby can wake several times overnight and still obtain plenty of sleep across 24 hours. How often a baby wakes, how long their longest uninterrupted stretch is and how much sleep they get altogether are related, but they aren't the same measure.
So we need to be careful about treating uninterrupted sleep as a simple measure of either sleep quality or healthy development.
Do babies have to learn to self-settle?
This is where the St James-Roberts video study becomes particularly interesting. Around a quarter of the five-week-old babies were observed waking and returning to sleep without signalling for their parents.
Five weeks is obviously far too young for anybody to have deliberately taught those babies a sophisticated settling strategy. That doesn't prove that self-settling is a fixed developmental milestone, or that every baby will begin doing it at a particular age. Nor does it tell us that parents have no influence on how children eventually learn to manage sleep. What it does tell us is that the capacity to wake and return to sleep without parental help can be present remarkably early, without formal teaching.
The same study also found that exclusively breastfed babies at three months were just as likely as formula or mixed-fed babies to resettle themselves during the night. This matters because parents are frequently told that feeding, rocking, holding or otherwise helping a baby to sleep will prevent them from ever being able to settle independently. The evidence doesn't support such a simple relationship.
A baby can sometimes fall asleep while feeding and sometimes return to sleep without help. They can need considerable support at one developmental stage and much less at another. They can settle differently with different people and in different circumstances.
Babies don't have to demonstrate independent settling at every sleep in order to show that they are capable of it. And independent settling isn't the only measure of healthy sleep.
Holistic sleep coaching covers the whole of childhood, birth through the teenage years, in one evidence-based framework.
Learn more about holistic sleep coaching →Parents matter, but not because they need the perfect technique
If sleep isn't simply something we teach babies to do, that doesn't mean parents are irrelevant.
Teti and colleagues (2010) observed families at bedtime and found an association between maternal emotional availability and infant sleep quality.
We need to be careful about what we conclude from that. It doesn't prove that emotionally available parenting causes babies to sleep better, and I certainly wouldn't want emotional availability to become another sleep strategy parents feel they have to perform correctly.
But it does fit with something we see repeatedly in practice: sleep happens within relationships. Babies don't experience bedtime as an isolated behavioural event. They bring their temperament, sensory preferences, feeding needs, health, development and current level of regulation with them. Parents bring their own capacity, expectations, emotions and circumstances too.
That is why I am much less interested in finding the perfect settling technique than I am in understanding what is happening around the sleep difficulty. Sometimes changing how a child settles is useful. Sometimes it isn't the thing that needs changing at all.
Normal sleep has a very wide range
There is one more reason we need to be cautious about defining good infant sleep according to a particular number of hours. Children vary enormously in how much sleep they need.
Population studies give us useful information about how sleep changes with age, but the variation between individual children is substantial (Iglowstein et al., 2003; Galland et al., 2012). It can be helpful to think of children as having relatively low, average or high sleep needs, while remembering that these aren't diagnostic categories.
One baby may genuinely need considerably more sleep across 24 hours than another baby of exactly the same age. They may distribute that sleep differently too. One child might have two substantial naps and a slightly shorter night. Another may barely nap and sleep for longer overnight. Another may sleep for the same total amount but wake and signal several times during the night.
This is why averages are useful for understanding populations but much less useful as individual prescriptions. If the average baby of a particular age sleeps for 14 hours, that doesn't mean the baby in front of us needs 14 hours. And it certainly doesn't mean that something has gone wrong if they don't.
So when does waking become a problem?
This is probably the question I care about most. Normalising night waking shouldn't mean dismissing it. A baby can be doing something developmentally ordinary and their parents can still be absolutely exhausted. A child can have a sleep pattern that falls within a broad range of normal and it can still be completely unsustainable for their family.
And sometimes frequent waking does tell us that something else needs attention. Pain, discomfort, feeding difficulties, breathing problems, iron deficiency, sensory needs, developmental changes, insufficient sleep pressure, family circumstances and many other things can affect sleep. So when a family tells me that their baby isn't sleeping through, I don't think the most useful response is either ‘that's normal’ or ‘we need to teach them to self-settle’.
I want to know what is actually happening.
- How much sleep is this child getting?
- How is it distributed?
- How often are they waking?
- What happens when they wake?
- Are they feeding?
- Do they seem uncomfortable?
- Has something changed?
- How much support do they need?
- And how is all of this affecting the family?
Because the problem we're trying to solve matters. If a baby is healthy, developing well and waking twice to breastfeed, but the parent has been told they should be sleeping for twelve uninterrupted hours, the work may be around expectation and reassurance.
If the same pattern is leaving a parent dangerously exhausted because they have no support and are returning to work, we have a different problem.
If a child is waking hourly and appears uncomfortable, we may need to look beyond sleep altogether.
And if a family simply wants to change something about the way sleep currently works, that's allowed too.
We don't need to pathologise a child's sleep before we're allowed to help a family change it.
References
- Galland, B. C., Taylor, B. J., Elder, D. E., & Herbison, P. (2012). Normal sleep patterns in infants and children: A systematic review of observational studies. Sleep Medicine Reviews, 16(3), 213–222.
- Iglowstein, I., Jenni, O. G., Molinari, L., & Largo, R. H. (2003). Sleep duration from infancy to adolescence: Reference values and generational trends. Pediatrics, 111(2), 302–307.
- Pennestri, M.-H., Laganiere, C., Bouvette-Turcot, A.-A., Pokhvisneva, I., Steiner, M., Meaney, M. J., & Gaudreau, H. (2018). Uninterrupted infant sleep, development, and maternal mood. Pediatrics, 142(6), e20174330.
- Pennestri, M.-H., Burdayron, R., Kenny, S., Béliveau, M.-J., & Dubois-Comtois, K. (2020). Sleeping through the night or through the nights? Sleep Medicine, 76, 98–103.
- St James-Roberts, I., Roberts, M., Hovish, K., & Owen, C. (2015). Video evidence that London infants can resettle themselves back to sleep after waking in the night, as well as sleep for long periods, by 3 months of age. Journal of Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics, 36(5), 324–329.
- Teti, D. M., Kim, B.-R., Mayer, G., & Countermine, M. (2010). Maternal emotional availability at bedtime predicts infant sleep quality. Journal of Family Psychology, 24(3), 307–315.
Why we teach sleep this way
This is the thinking behind the Holistic Sleep Coaching Program.
We teach the science of sleep, but we also teach people how to assess the child and family in front of them.
That means understanding sleep physiology and development alongside feeding, health, sensory needs, relationships, family circumstances and parental capacity. It means knowing what is broadly normal without using normality to dismiss somebody who is struggling. And it means being able to support change without assuming that every baby needs to sleep for twelve uninterrupted hours or fall asleep independently.
The Holistic Sleep Coaching Program is an evidence-based, assessment-first course for professionals who work with families, including doulas, IBCLCs, health visitors, midwives, maternity nurses and sleep practitioners who want to develop their knowledge further.
It is accredited at Level 6 through the Open College Network, taught by a faculty of international specialists and includes live clinical supervision.
If this is how you want to think about sleep, you can book a free call with the team to find out more.
Watch the free 4-part video training
Enter your details below and we'll send you straight to the Holistic Sleep Coaching Revolution: a free video series with Dr Lyndsey Hookway and Emma Dewey. You'll see why surface-level sleep advice often falls short, how to support families responsively while still achieving results, and how to build a trusted sleep consultancy on that foundation. Instant access — watch at your own pace.
Completely free, with instant access — watch in any order that suits you. You'll also receive our emails about all things sleep; unsubscribe any time. We protect your details in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
What happens when practitioners choose depth
“Fully booked in less than 12 months.”
Lucy Bagwell“6 clients a month to 6 a week, with a waitlist.”
Karla“The Holistic programme goes into areas that other courses just don't touch, and as a result it has given me the breadth and depth of knowledge I was really looking for.”
Rachael TaylorSleep Coach“For me it was a degree-level professional education on everything you need to know about sleep, not just a philosophy to follow. I've done lots of training and hands down this is the most comprehensive.”
Nadia EdwardsHSCP GraduateFrequently asked questions
What is holistic sleep coaching?
How is it different from traditional sleep training?
Is the programme accredited?
Do I need previous qualifications or experience to join?
What support do I get during and after the course?
What is your refund and cancellation policy?
Within 14 days of purchase: you can cancel and request a full refund.
After 14 days: cancellations are not eligible for a refund.
To request a refund, email info@babyem.co.uk.
Still reading? That's usually a sign.
Watch the free training →